By Annie · Last checked 13 November 2026 · Evidence: documentation review
Short answer: The ICO published brief guidance on 11 November 2026 about subject access requests that appear to have been generated or drafted with AI. Three points matter for a small UK firm. A request is still valid if AI helped to write it. The usual one-month deadline still applies. And you are only required to make a reasonable and proportionate search, not to follow every location or category an AI-written letter may list. This is a documentation review of the ICO's page, which I opened on 13 November 2026. It is general information, not legal advice.
What the ICO published
The page is titled "Subject access requests generated by artificial intelligence". The ICO says it was published on 11 November 2026. It covers SARs under article 15 of the UK GDPR, and the ICO says much of it is still relevant if you are considering an AI-assisted request under Part 3 (law enforcement).
The ICO uses the term "AI-assisted SARs" for requests that appear to have been generated using AI or drafted with the assistance of AI. It says AI can help people exercise their right of access, especially if they are unsure how to make a request. It also says those requests can be harder to understand: lengthy, repetitive, broad or unclear; focused on metadata or material that would typically fall outside a reasonable search; or inaccurate, including legal references from other jurisdictions or several different rights and complaints mixed into one letter.
The ICO points readers to its longer right of access guidance for more detail on each topic. This page is a plain-English briefing of the new brief, not a substitute for that longer guidance or for advice on a live case.
A request is still valid if AI drafted it
The ICO's answer is direct: "A request isn’t invalid just because a person used AI to help draft it. You must treat an AI-assisted SAR in the same way as any other SAR."
What matters, the ICO says, is whether it is clear that the person is asking for their personal information. They do not need to use specific wording or cite the correct provisions of data protection law.
The same is true if the letter contains mistakes. The ICO says AI-assisted SARs may misstate rights, quote laws from other jurisdictions, refer to non-existent case law or give a wrong address. A SAR is still valid if it is clear the person wants access to their personal information. If a correspondence address is included, the ICO says you should check it against the contact details you hold, and you are still responsible for the security of the personal information you hold.
The ICO also warns that fraudulent actors may use AI to create false ID or letters of authority. If you are unsure about identity or authority, it says you should verify this with the person, and if you think a letter of authority may have been generated with AI, you should contact the person the request is about directly.
The one-month deadline still applies
The ICO says the time limit for an AI-assisted SAR is the same as for any other SAR. You must respond as soon as possible and no later than one month. The month starts when you receive the SAR, any required ID, proof that a third party is authorised, or a fee where one has been requested.
Using AI does not, by itself, buy you more time. The ICO says the use of AI doesn't automatically make a SAR complex, and that a request isn't complex simply because it is lengthy, unclear, convoluted or includes legal references. Volume alone doesn't make it complex. If you decide a request is complex, the ICO says you may extend the time limit by up to a further two months, and you must contact the person and explain why.
If the request is unclear, the ICO says you can ask for clarification where that is reasonably required. You can't make the person narrow their request. The ICO says the clock stops when you ask for clarification and resumes when you receive it, so ask promptly if you need to.
A reasonable, proportionate search is enough
The ICO says that in responding to any SAR, including an AI-assisted one, you must make a reasonable and proportionate search. That means reasonable efforts to identify and retrieve information about the person from locations where it is likely to be held. It may involve searching more than one department and, where relevant, contacting processors or joint controllers.
You don't have to carry out searches that are unreasonable or disproportionate to the importance of providing access, the ICO says, but you must be able to justify that. It is generally reasonable to confine searches to areas where information is likely to be held. You should not narrow the scope, limit searches or make assumptions about what the person wants without consulting them.
An AI-assisted SAR may list particular datasets, backups, platforms, CCTV or call logs. The ICO says it is still your responsibility to decide the parameters of a reasonable and proportionate search. If you aren't sure what they are asking for, you could ask for further details. You should record whether you sought the requester's views, what you included or excluded, and why.
If someone asks for "all of my personal information including metadata", the ICO says a reasonable and proportionate search won't necessarily mean you have to search for every category of metadata or system-generated audit information, though that depends on the circumstances. If they specifically ask for particular metadata, or if metadata is reasonably likely to contain relevant personal information, you should consider whether you need to search for and provide it. If "metadata" is unclear, you could ask what they mean.
The same exemptions may apply as for any other SAR. The ICO says there are no special rules or exemptions that apply only to AI-assisted requests. Using AI to draft a SAR doesn't, by itself, make it manifestly unfounded or excessive.
A practical checklist for a small firm

When a long, formal-looking request arrives, the ICO's own practical steps are a good starting point. In short:
- Treat it as a SAR if it's clear they want their personal information, even if AI appears to have drafted it, and even if the legal citations look wrong.
- Start the one-month clock from receipt of the request and any required ID, authority or fee. Diary the date. Don't assume AI makes it complex.
- Check the correspondence address against the details you hold, and verify identity or authority if you are unsure, especially if a third party is involved.
- Decide, and write down, the scope of a reasonable and proportionate search. Search where the information is likely to be held. You don't have to follow every location the letter lists, but you should be able to justify what you excluded, and you should not narrow the request without consulting them.
- Ask for clarification promptly if you reasonably need it, and remember the ICO says the clock pauses until the clarification arrives. You can also contact the person informally to explain what you hold and that you only have to make a reasonable search.
- Don't refuse it just because it's long, formal or mentions AI. The ICO says people may use AI because they think formal language will be taken more seriously, not because they are trying to cause disruption. If you later rely on the manifestly unfounded or excessive provisions, you must be able to justify that.
- Give staff a named contact and a short written process, so a long letter is not ignored or answered late. The ICO says you should train staff to recognise a SAR and, for those who handle requests, how to check details and verify identity.
- Make it easy to ask you directly. The ICO says you can publish clear guidance and optional templates, remind people to review an AI-assisted request before sending it, and you could warn them not to put personal information, especially sensitive information, into AI tools.
Our ICO AI guidance tracker lists the ICO's other AI publications, including the agentic AI call for evidence. For the wider UK GDPR picture, see AI agents and UK GDPR.
Frequently asked questions
Is a subject access request still valid if AI drafted it?
Yes. The ICO's guidance, published 11 November 2026, says a request isn't invalid just because a person used AI to help draft it. You must treat an AI-assisted SAR in the same way as any other SAR. What matters is whether it's clear that the person is asking for their personal information.
Does the one-month deadline still apply to an AI-drafted SAR?
Yes. The ICO says the time limit is the same as for any other SAR. You must respond as soon as possible and no later than one month. The month starts when you receive the SAR, any required ID, proof that a third party is authorised, or a fee where one has been requested. If the request is complex, the ICO says you may extend the time limit by up to a further two months, and you must contact the person and explain why.
Do I have to search every place an AI-drafted SAR lists?
No. The ICO says you must make a reasonable and proportionate search: reasonable efforts to find information in places where it is likely to be held. You don't have to carry out searches that are unreasonable or disproportionate, but you must be able to justify that, and you should record what you included or excluded and why. You should not narrow the scope without consulting the requester, and you can't make them narrow their request.
Does using AI automatically make a SAR complex?
No. The ICO says the use of AI doesn't automatically make a SAR complex, and that a request isn't complex simply because it's lengthy, unclear, convoluted or includes legal references. You assess it in the same way as any other SAR. Volume alone doesn't make it complex.
Can I refuse an AI-drafted SAR as manifestly unfounded or excessive?
Not just because AI was used. The ICO says using AI to draft a SAR doesn't, by itself, make the request manifestly unfounded or excessive. If you rely on those provisions, you must be able to justify the decision. A request isn't necessarily excessive just because it asks for a large amount of information.
Sources
- Information Commissioner's Office, "Subject access requests generated by artificial intelligence", published 11 November 2026, opened 13 November 2026: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/subject-access-requests/subject-access-requests-generated-by-artificial-intelligence/
See also: ICO AI guidance tracker · AI agents and UK GDPR · AI policy and DPIA templates · AI supplier due diligence checklist
Last checked: 13 November 2026 (Europe/London). Evidence: documentation review of the ICO page listed above, which opened successfully on 13 November 2026. I have not handled a live subject access request for this guide. General information, not legal advice. How we test. Editorial policy.



